Cheryl Fossyl, 16, disappeared from Georgetown, Ohio on June 4, 1977. Her remains were found in two places in the following weeks. Brown County reopened the case in 2001 and a grand jury heard 40-plus witnesses without indicting anyone. In 2007 her siblings won a civil verdict against two men. No one has been criminally charged.
The Fossyl case shows the gap between civil and criminal proof. A jury decided in 2007 that two men were responsible for her death, but prosecutors said there was no forensic evidence linking anyone, no living eyewitnesses, and no confession. Murder has no statute of limitations, so the criminal case could be reopened.
Editorial assessment of public sources, not a finding of fact. Nobody named here has been charged unless this page says so.
Details come from a Maysville Ledger Independent report on the 2002 grand jury and a FOX19 report on the 2007 civil verdict. Some dates are inferred, as marked.
Cheryl Fossyl, 16, disappears from Georgetown, Ohio.
Four boys fishing near a bridge over Straight Creek on US 68 find part of her remains. Sources differ on the exact date.
Her nude body is found in a creek bed in Adams County.
Brown County Sheriff Dwayne Wenninger reopens the case shortly after taking office. One secondary account says a deathbed statement from a woman prompted the reopening; we could not confirm that and treat it as unverified.
Her body is exhumed from Tate Township Cemetery in Bethel and taken to Dayton for DNA testing and a full autopsy, which was not done in 1977.
County commissioners ask for a special prosecutor. The county prosecutor steps down from the case after the family's lawyer alleges conflicts. A Hamilton County assistant prosecutor is appointed.
A special grand jury meets six times starting May 8 and hears from more than 40 witnesses. It returns no indictments, finding insufficient evidence for a murder trial.
A jury rules that two men sued by her brothers and sister are responsible for her murder. The report says there was never enough evidence for a criminal case.
A 16-year-old whose family never stopped asking.
Disappeared from Georgetown on June 4, 1977. Her brothers and sister pursued the case for about 30 years, according to FOX19.
We found no freely licensed photo, so a silhouette is shown. Family members or others who want a photo added, changed, or removed can use the contact form at the bottom of this page.
What exists, and what each piece may or may not mean.
| Item | What is known | Disputed or unknown |
|---|---|---|
| Remains | Found in two locations: near US 68 at Straight Creek, and in an Adams County creek bed. | Dates differ by source. Condition of the scene: not public. |
| Cause of death | Reports say she was beaten. A full autopsy was done after the 2001 exhumation. | The autopsy report is not public. |
| Forensic evidence | The special prosecutor said no forensic evidence linked anyone to the crime. | DNA results from the exhumation: not public. |
| Witnesses | More than 40 witnesses testified to the grand jury. | Prosecutors said there were no living eyewitnesses. Statements are secret. |
| Case file | A later report said very little of the original file could be found. | Whether evidence from 1977 survives: not public. |
Court records of the 2007 civil trial should be public. Grand jury records are secret.
| Document | Holder | What it shows | Access |
|---|---|---|---|
| FOX19: Jury rules 2 men responsible (2007) | FOX19 | The civil verdict. | Online, free |
| Maysville Ledger Independent: grand jury report | Maysville Ledger Independent | Exhumation, special prosecutor, grand jury. | Online, free |
| Civil case file | Brown County Common Pleas Court | Testimony and exhibits from the 2007 trial. | Request needed |
| Grand jury record | Brown County | Secret by law. | Withheld or sealed |
Access labels: Online, free = we could open it. Fan-hosted copy = a private researcher posted scans; originals are held by the named agency, and we cannot vouch for completeness. Quoted in news = reporters read it; we did not see the document itself. Request needed = held by an agency or court. Withheld = the holder has not released it. We cannot reach non-public records, and we do not try to.
Where people talk about this case online, and how to read it.
| Platform | Live search | What you tend to find |
|---|---|---|
| Google: Reddit | site:reddit.com search | Public Reddit threads that Google has indexed, including old discussions. |
| Google: X and Twitter | X and Twitter posts | Public posts and profiles that appear in search results. |
| Google: Facebook | Public Facebook pages and posts | Only public pages and groups that Google can see. Private groups never appear. |
| Google: Instagram and TikTok | Instagram and TikTok | Public posts, memorials, and videos. |
| Google: forums | Forums and message boards | Long-running true-crime forums. |
| Google News | Latest news | Newest reporting, which is usually more reliable than posts. |
| Search Reddit | Long discussion threads and theories, often by amateur researchers. No sign-in needed to read. | |
| X (Twitter) | Search X | Short posts, news links, and anniversary notes. May require sign-in. |
| Search Facebook | Public groups and family or community pages. Requires sign-in. | |
| Search #cherylfossyl | Memorial and true-crime posts. Requires sign-in. | |
| YouTube | Search YouTube | Documentaries, news clips, and interviews. Quality varies widely. |
Be careful with online theories. Naming a private person as a suspect can harm an innocent family, and many "identifications" on forums have been wrong. Our own tools could not read these platforms: Reddit blocks automated access, and the others require an account. The Google searches above work from your browser. To get new public mentions by email, make a free Google Alert for the case name in quotation marks.
What local and national reports say, and when we last checked for a solution.
| Date | Outlet | What it reported | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| About 2002 (undated) | |||
| Maysville Ledger Independent | |||
| Grand jury hears 40+ witnesses and returns no indictments. | |||
| Read | |||
| Nov 16, 2007 | |||
| FOX19 | |||
| Civil jury finds two men responsible; no criminal charge. | |||
| Read |
Status is re-checked on a regular schedule. If you know of a development we missed, use the clue form near the top of this page or the contact form, and include a link.
No one has been criminally charged. A civil jury named two men.
Why named: Her brothers and sister sued two men who were in their 20s in 1977. A jury ruled in Nov 2007 that they were responsible for her murder.
Against: The standard of proof was civil. A grand jury had declined to indict. Prosecutors said no forensic evidence linked anyone and there was no confession.
Why named: The family's lawyer said in 2002 that at least two people responsible were still at large.
Against: No further detail is public.
Where a card shows a silhouette, we found no photo. Anyone who wants a photo added, changed, or removed can use the contact form at the bottom of this page.
The most important open question is what the civil jury heard that the grand jury did not, or weighed differently.
We put the chance that the 2007 civil verdict identified at least one person involved at roughly 60%, because a jury heard evidence we cannot see. We hold it below the criminal standard because a grand jury that heard 40 witnesses declined to indict and no forensic link was found.
Editorial judgment, not statistics.
"—" means no public information, not a clean result.
| Person or idea | Civil finding | Physical link | Criminal outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two men in the civil case (unnamed) | ✓ jury found responsible (2007) | — none published | ? grand jury: no indictment |
| Unknown others | ? per family lawyer | — none published | — unidentified |
✗ excluded or contradicted · ✓ supports · ? disputed · — nothing public. No cell is an official finding.
Editorial reading of public records. A working theory, not a finding, and it names no individual.
Judgment, not statistics.
Questions raised by gaps in the public record.
Testimony and exhibits from the 2007 trial in Brown County.
Results from Dayton Forensics and whether samples remain.
The family sought recovery of remains that were still missing in 2002.
What happened to the original investigative file.
The last people who saw her, and the car she reportedly got into.
What the sheriff relied on in 2001, including the reported deathbed statement.
"Not public" means we could not find a report.
| Item | Tested | Gap |
|---|---|---|
| Exhumation autopsy and DNA | Done in 2001 or 2002. | Results: not public. |
| Grand jury testimony | Heard from 40+ witnesses. | Secret by law. |
| Civil trial exhibits | Presented in 2007. | Not reviewed by us. |
| Sheriff's file | Reopened in 2001. | A later report said little of the original file remained. |
| Tool | What it could do | Status here |
|---|---|---|
| DNA from retained evidence | Identify a donor or exclude people. | Unknown; not reported |
| Forensic genetic genealogy | Identify an unknown donor from relatives. | Needs usable DNA; none reported |
| Ballistics database (NIBIN) | Link recovered casings or bullets to other crimes. | Not reported |
Local cases that moved after decades.
Investigators say a private genealogy investigation helped them identify Thomas Dunaway, who died in 1990, as the man who killed the 16-year-old. He cannot be indicted, so prosecutors sent a letter saying he would have been charged. The lesson: genealogy can name a killer after decades, even when no trial is possible.
In 2024, local investigators were being trained in the technique, which has already helped solve Cincinnati-area cases, according to FOX19. The lesson: the tool is now local, so cases with usable DNA have a real path forward.
Old crime-scene DNA matched relatives in a public database and led to a 2018 arrest. The lesson: a usable sample can still work after decades.
Case details come from public news coverage and the Boone County Sheriff's cold-case list. Confirm in court records.
| Claim | Source and date | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|
| The civil verdict proves guilt | Reasonable reading of the 2007 report | It is a civil finding. No criminal case was brought. |
| A deathbed confession reopened the case | A secondary account | We could not confirm it. Treat as unverified. |
| Dates of the discoveries | Various | Sources differ on the exact days. We give approximate timing. |
She disappeared from Georgetown. Her remains were found along US 68 at Straight Creek in Brown County and in a creek bed in Adams County.
Open in maps: Georgetown, Ohio. We show no photograph of the scene.
| Source | Type | Rating | Use with care because |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maysville Ledger Independent (2002 grand jury report) | Regional news | B | Undated in the copy we read; the year is inferred. |
| FOX19, Nov 16, 2007 | Local news | B+ | Brief. Quotes the family's lawyer. |
| Forum reposts of a longer feature | User-posted | D | Secondhand. We did not rely on it. |
Lead agency since the 2001 reopening.
The 2007 civil case brought by her siblings.
Any new criminal review.
Under the Ohio Public Records Act, I request copies of non-exempt records relating to the June 1977 homicide of Cheryl Fossyl in Georgetown, Brown County, including incident reports, laboratory reports, and any evidence inventory. Please send electronic copies. If any part is withheld, please identify the exemption relied on and release all reasonably segregable material.
Agencies often withhold records of open investigations, so expect partial answers.
Cheryl was 16. Her siblings spent about 30 years seeking answers.
Loading headlines…
Every fact on this page comes from one of these. Where they disagree, we say so above.
Years for the exhumation, special prosecutor, and grand jury are inferred from the 2001 reopening. The reported deathbed statement is from a secondary source and is unverified. We found no reporting after Nov 2007.